đˇ Image Credits: TechCrunch
The social media platform Elon Musk’s X is getting ready to make “likes” private. This move might make it difficult for users to distinguish between content they’ve bookmarked and content they’ve favorited. Employees of the corporation have posted fresh content, claiming that the purpose of hiding likes is to safeguard people’s reputations and encourage interaction by letting them favorite content that strikes them as “edgy.”
It’s unclear if this is the ideal way to address the issues X is attempting to resolve, including giving its system more signal so it can more accurately tailor its material to your interests.
Given that X, the corporation that was formerly known as Twitter, already offered a private option to save posts on the platformâbookmarksâthe adjustment seems a little pointless. Although X’s bookmarks are designed to save topics or threads you might wish to read later, they also functioned as a more discreet option to “like.”
Users will be able to view who liked their posts and the total number of likes for all of their answers and posts, which further adds to the confusion. Put otherwise, a private “like” is only semi-secret because the poster is aware of it and could potentially reveal someone’s likes if they so choose. Given that it’s not a fully private system, people might still be reluctant to “like” postings that contain explicit content or take extreme political stances, for example, if X is attempting to encourage “edgy” engagement.
Instead, people might keep saving those favorite posts they don’t want to take the chance of exposing using X’s bookmarks or even third-party link-saving software.
Employees of X have posted that users would no longer be able to explore someone’s likes through a tab on their profile or see the likes connected to other people’s postings. This takes away a helpful function for discovery but may also help stop others from spying.
For example, if you’re new to X, you may look through the profiles of people you follow to see who else they would find intriguing. Alternatively, you may use someone else’s likes to gain an idea of the kinds of stuff they typically enjoy when looking through their profile to decide whether or not to follow them.
The true issue with likes is that their introduction changed the purpose of the bookmarking function. The feature was more of a “favorite” than a show of support before it was rebrandedâas was popular at the timeâfrom a star to a heart icon. It was theoretically possible for users to favorite anything, as doing so did not imply that they genuinely liked or agreed with the content.
Instead, it might have been something they were just recording, like a politician’s remarks you strongly disagreed with but wanted to keep in mind, a post that needed more investigation, a collection of posts you were gathering to eventually compile in Moments (RIP), the most disturbing or absurd posts made by a billionaire, and more. You have plausible deniability since no one could legitimately claim that you were “liking” the content because you weren’t clicking the heart icon.
Users were furious when Twitter changed from stars to hearts. They realized that hearts meant something completely different, and that changed their behaviour on the social network.
The Favourite feature, on the other hand, might indicate a variety of things, such a “thank you, a handshake, a tip of the hat, or even a Robert De Niro stare down,” according to TechCrunch at the time. At the time, TechCrunch predicted that switching from stars to hearts wouldn’t address Twitter’s more significant problems with increasing user numbers and engagement, and in most cases, it didn’t. After nearly constant growth for several quarters, the corporation had to find a way out.
Twitter later introduced Bookmarks to bring back the ability to save private content, including postings you didn’t necessarily agree with and ones you meant to refer to again in response to the criticism over the change.
Now that X is once more rearranging the functionality surrounding the “like,” a lot of people are expressing their displeasure. Many alternatives to this proposed change are being discussed on X, such as making private likes an option rather than a default and allowing anonymous “likes” via long-pressing the heart icon. Others cautioned that since artists used legions of bots to promote their material and help them make money, privatizing likes could lead to manipulation.
Additionally, there is a different approach, which former Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey hinted at. Even while we disagree with a lot of what Dorsey says these daysâthat Nostr is the social media of the future, for example, or that Bluesky is a platform for censorshipâhe makes sense when it comes to the likes vs. stars argument.
In a post on X, Dorsey wrote: “‘like’/â¤ď¸ was once a âď¸. We ought never to have strayed from that.
More than 700 people have liked his post, and numerous comments have echoed his thoughts.
X doesn’t need to hide likes if its goal is to add additional signals for its algorithm rather than more privacy surrounding user engagement features. To achieve the same result, a much less drastic alteration would be to simply replace the heart icon with a star.